SuperSlow vs Pilates.
If you want measurable strength gains, cardiovascular improvement and improved bone density with the smallest weekly time commitment, SuperSlow is the clear choice. If you are currently participating in regular strength training and want additional core control, postural awareness, and flexibility in a flowing class format, Pilates is a great complimentary addition. The honest answer is that they are completely separate activities, and should not be viewed as alternative forms of exercise. Below: how the two compare, with citations.
- ✔ SuperSlow: 30 minutes once a week, builds maximum strength and bone density.
- ✔ Pilates: 50 to 60 minutes, 2 to 3 times a week, builds core, posture, and flexibility.
- ✔ They are complementary, not competing. Pick by primary goal, or do both.
The two methods, compared.
| Dimension | SuperSlow | Pilates |
|---|---|---|
| Time per week | 30 minutes, one session | 100 to 180 minutes, 2 to 3 sessions |
| Primary goal | Maximum strength and bone density | Core control, posture, flexibility |
| Supervision | 1-on-1, every rep | Solo, group, or 1-on-1 reformer |
| Joint impact | Very low | Very low |
| Equipment | Matrix and MedX machines | Reformer, mat, Cadillac, chair |
| Cardio benefit | High during the set | Modest, depends on style |
| Cost per week | $50 session + $49/mo facility (~$56/wk) | $30 to $90 per private session, 2 to 3x |
| Ideal for | Strength, bone density, cardiovascular | Posture, core, dancers, flexibility |
Pros
- Drives measurable strength gain on a tracked weekly chart
- Strong bone-density stimulus, useful for women 50+ and osteoporosis
- Improves cardiovascular health and endurance
- One 30-minute appointment per week, easy to schedule
- Always 1-on-1 with the same trainer
Cons
- Does not directly train flexibility or postural patterning
- Requires the right machines and a trainer who knows the method
Pros
- Excellent for postural awareness and core control
- Improves flexibility and movement quality
- Low force movement is gentle on joints
- Available in many formats, mat to reformer
Cons
- Light loading limits strength and bone density gains
- Group classes lack the per-rep correction of 1-on-1 work
- 2 to 3 sessions per week is a real time commitment
Pick by goal.
Dr. Doug McGuff defines exercise as "a purposefully directed activity that safely stimulates positive physiological adaptations to enhance fitness and health, without undermining either in the process." Because Pilates does not incorporate meaningful resistance, it can not stimulate adaptive strength responses and therefore can not be considered true exercise. It does however offer benefits that do not undermine health and fitness, so could be viewed as a complementary activity to a proper strength training program. A plethora of research exists emphasizing the cardiovascular system, bone density and skeletal muscle all respond positively to muscular fatigue through progressive resistance. This is why strength training stands alone and SuperSlow training has the edge.
Pick SuperSlow if:
- Your priority is strength, bone density, or cardiovascular improvement
- You have 30 minutes a week, not 3 hours
- You want a quantified, tracked progress
Pick Pilates if:
- Your priority is core control, posture, or flexibility
- You enjoy a flowing class format
- You are already strength training and want more flexibility
Do both if: you have the time and budget. Many of our clients in Santa Rosa pair a weekly SuperSlow session with one or two Pilates classes. The strength session leaves plenty of recovery for the postural work.
Fact-check it yourself.
- Mayo Clinic strength training guidelines
- NIH on exercise and bone health
- Harvard Health on back pain
- WebMD on slow-tempo strength training
Joseph Pilates developed his method in the 1920s as rehabilitation work. Ken Hutchins formalized SuperSlow in the early 1980s during an osteoporosis study. Both have decades of clinical use behind them. They aim at different outcomes.
Comparison FAQ.
If your question is not here, reach out, we answer every email personally.
Book your free session →Is Pilates a form of strength training?
Can I do both Pilates and SuperSlow?
Which is better for back pain?
Which is better for bone density?
How much time per week does each take?
Keep going.
Try the method once,
return for life.
Meet your trainer, discuss your goals, review your history, and perform the SuperSlow method. No obligation to book a second session, unless you feel we are the right fit for you.
Book your free session →